I’m a big fan of vows. But if we’re not careful, they can be unused, devalued, misused, or even abused.
Let me start with the value of a vow. Judaism prizes the idea that “my word is my bond” – not just to others, but also to myself and to God. Verbally spoken commitments must be adhered to. If I say I will not eat sugar for the next thirty days, then for the next month, sugar is equivalent to pork in Jewish law. A commitment I make to myself is just as weighty as one imposed upon me by God. And hence, the value of a vow.
When there’s something I want to stick to, let’s say a diet, but I know that temptation might trip me up, I make a vow. Orthodox Jewish smokers who might struggle to resist cigarettes all week, will refrain completely on Shabbat – not because the desire vanishes, but because the boundary is sacred and real. So too, a vow creates a sacred boundary for me, one that I adhere to far more easily. That’s why I love vows: they help me get where I want to go.
However, here are the pitfalls.
Abuse – this is the obvious one. History offers many examples where solemn commitments were exploited as tools of deception, turning trust into a weapon. The Munich Agreement is a classic case. This is using something holy and precious for the profane purpose of personal gain. Hopefully, that’s unthinkable for any of us.
Misuse is a level below. You make commitments without really intending to keep them. You’ll try your best, but if it doesn’t happen, it doesn’t happen. This is a real shame, because it leads to the next one.
Devaluation – this is where we find ourselves today in many areas. And once the value of a vow is lost, it’s hard to get it back. The classic example, in my mind, is marriage. There was a time when marriage meant “till death do us part.” We are absolutely and utterly committed through thick and thin. If you’re in a car crash the day after the wedding becoming a quadriplegic and sending all our dreams up in smoke, I’m still here for you for the next sixty years – till the end of my life or yours.
Whenever I stand under a marriage canopy to marry a young couple nowadays, I can’t help but feel that for many it’s no longer “till death do us part,” but “till this no longer serves my interests do us part,” or “till divorce do us part.” And of course, this is a self-fulfilling prophecy. Which comes first – the chicken of lack of commitment, or the egg of failed marriages? As in the Garden of Eden, I would suggest the chicken precedes the egg. It’s not that people see so many failed marriages and are scared to commit; rather, we live in a time when people don’t want to commit in case something better comes along – and that lack of commitment leads to failed marriages.
This brings me to the final pitfall: unused. In the Orthodox Jewish world today, people will never make a vow – for fear of breaking it! To me, that’s like not applying for a job in case I don’t get it. When fear of things going wrong is the guiding factor, we doom ourselves to mediocrity. Playing safe and greatness are not compatible bedfellows.
To me, vows are a gift – and it’s a great shame to miss out on them. There’s a simple solution to the Orthodox fear: make vows and keep them! Be committed. Avoiding commitment means achieving little. Of course, be responsible and sensible. Don’t vow things you might not be able to live up to. But use the gift of vows. Make commitments and follow them through. This is how we climb the ladder of Godliness. And even if we don’t quite reach the skies – let’s not allow fear of failure stop us from climbing as far as we can.
Shabbat Shalom
