|

Is Forgiveness a Jewish Idea? A Case for Yes

Add a heading 1 e1751990324849
Reading Time: 3 minutes

With Yom Kippur coming up, I thought I would talk about forgiveness.

I recently saw a comment by a fellow rabbi about Erika Kirk’s statement that she had forgiven the man who killed her husband. He said that this was not a Jewish idea.

Whilst I understand his perspective, I’m inclined to disagree.

Forgiveness is a feeling, not a word, nor even an action. Forgiveness means that, in your heart, you feel no ill will to the person who wronged you. It doesn’t mean that you are not cautious not to get hurt again. Forgiveness doesn’t mean you have no common sense. It doesn’t mean that you would necessarily trust the person or even want a relationship with them. It just means that you do not take to heart the specific wrong they have done you.

I believe there are two beliefs that would lead someone to forgive. I will talk about the one that is most fundamentally grounded in Jewish philosophy.

There is a very strong and widely held idea in Judaism that God controls all that happens to us. Whilst a person might do us harm, that person was ultimately an agent of God. Now, you might have a thousand questions about this. What about freewill? What if the person had not done this, would God have found a different way to produce a similar outcome? What if the person had chosen to, but God didn’t want – would he have intervened? And a few more. They are valid questions and there are better answers to some than others, but the underlying belief remains. What happens to us is from God, not people. Even when people are those that choose to carry it out.

If this is so, then it is God who is responsible for harm that comes our way, not others. That doesn’t mean that a person didn’t do a wrong act and that God will not hold them accountable; he most certainly will. But that is between God and that person, nothing to do with anyone else, As far as a ‘victim’ is concerned, the ‘perpetrator’ is only God. This harm would have happened with or without the human choices.

I think that for someone who genuinely believed this idea of God’s full control, forgiveness would be very natural. Rather than anger and upset towards another human being, they would rather turn their attention to soul searching and reflection as to why God might have wanted this to happen. I believe that someone with this belief would find forgiveness quite easy. Because for a person with a genuine feeling of faith, there would be no reason for them to look anywhere else but themselves to understand why this happened to them.

In this sense, forgiveness would not be an ideal, nor an expectation; simply a consequence of a deep sense of belief in Divine providence.

I’m not suggesting how anyone should or shouldn’t feel, just pointing out that given how we Jews see the world, forgiveness would be almost a natural consequence. And instead of seeking to blame, we would more likely seek to stand up and take responsibility for our own lives and our own choices – something that Yom Kippur is very much all about.

The portion ends with Moses being told to ascend Mount Nevo to see the Promised Land before he dies and is ‘gathered to his people’. This turn of phrase, the Rabbis explain, is an allusion to the afterlife.

It’s all set up and ready for the tragic and yet uplifting climax. Make sure you tune in to a local Synagogue on Simchas Torah for the epic denouement.

Shabbat Shalom


Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *